About

A Church Reborn

A 1920s church in Flagler Village, rebuilt as a steakhouse and late-night room.

Jay's dining room with towering crystal chandeliers, a stained glass window, red velvet drapes, the DJ booth and set tables

Jay's sits inside a restored 1920s church in the heart of Flagler Village. The sanctuary's bones are still here — a stone facade, tall arched windows, vaulted ceilings, and the original stained glass — now set against leather booths, deep velvet, and candlelight.

Early in the evening it's a proper steakhouse: USDA Prime and dry-aged cuts, a raw bar that changes with the catch, and a bar that takes its cocktails and wine seriously. Later the lights come down and the music comes up — live bands, DJs, and cabaret across three bars that keep the night going.

It's a room that does two things at once: dinner worth dressing for and a night worth staying out for — steak, drinks, and a little showmanship under one very old roof.

Good to Know

Before You Visit

The Church Room

The main hall, and the room with the stage. Set inside our restored 1920s church — vaulted ceilings, original stained glass, candlelight — with live entertainment every night and a front-row seat to all of it.

The Parlor Room

Just off the main hall, with no view of the stage. The quieter, more intimate side of Jay's: the same menu and the same energy, set slightly apart from the show. The right choice for conversation.

Want to see the show? Request the Church Room when you book.

Dress Code: Business casual. We kindly ask guests to avoid shorts, tank tops, baseball caps, flip-flops, sweatpants, and swimwear. Jackets are not required, but encouraged for gentlemen.
Corkage: Outside wine is welcome. A $45 corkage fee applies per 750ml bottle.
Cake Cutting: Bringing your own celebration cake? A $35 cake-cutting fee applies.

Press